ADDITIONAL CLARIFICATION — WERE WOMEN COMMANDED TO REMAIN SILENT?
The question of women remaining silent in the church, particularly in 1 Timothy 2 and 1 Corinthians chapters 11 and 14, deserves far more than three minutes to properly explain.
However, because this question came up in response to one of my Shorts, I wanted to provide a brief response.
Unfortunately, I ran out of time after reading 1 Corinthians 14:34–35, before reaching what I believe is the most important part of Paul’s response: verse 36!
Paul writes:
“What? came the word of God out from you? or came it unto you only?” (1 Corinthians 14:36, KJV)
I believe verses 34–35 represent a restrictive position being presented to Paul, which he then challenges in verse 36. This is known as the quotation-and-refutation interpretation of the passage.
Notice that verse 34 says women should remain silent “as also saith the law.” Yet nowhere in the Old Testament Law do we find a command universally requiring women to remain silent in the assembly of God’s people.
We do, however, find restrictions concerning women’s public religious participation in later rabbinic traditions. Such traditions must not be confused with the written Law of Moses.
Furthermore, in 1 Corinthians 11:5, Paul acknowledges women praying and prophesying. How could Paul recognize women speaking prophetically and then issue an absolute prohibition against their speaking?
This is precisely why I believe verses 34–35 must be understood in connection with Paul’s response in verse 36.
There is much more to examine, including the historical setting, the Greek language, and the relationship between rabbinic traditions and the teachings of Christ.
My central point remains: We must not take an isolated passage and use it to silence women when the broader testimony of Scripture recognizes women praying, prophesying, and participating in the work of God.
I intend to address this subject in greater depth because it deserves careful examinatio